Blind v. color blind: the injustice of State felon disenfranchisement schemes
citation_date
2009
Description
State policies which disenfranchise ex-felons, those who have served their complete sentences, have a long history. While "civil death" was a common punishment
for convicts in Europe prior to the colonization of North America, ex-felon disenfranchisement statutes were adopted by several states, primarily in the South after
the Civil War. There is substantial evidence that these statutes were created to exclude racial minorities. These discriminatory effects can still be seen today. Racial minorities in the United States, primarily African Americans, are incarcerated at a much higher rate
than their white peers. Once convicted, these persons are often subject to disenfranchisement. Because of the racial disparities in conviction and incarceration,
minority communities are often left with a diminished voice in the electoral process.
Under the Voting Rights Act, as amended in 1982, any voting qualifications established by a state that result in disproportionate disadvantages for minorities are illegal. As a result, African American voters, who consistently vote for Democratic candidates 90% of the time, suffer from vote dilution due to felon disenfranchisement. Precedent suggests that courts analyzing such state statutes should consider a totality of circumstances,
including the historical reasons for enactment and other harms suffered by the community. Ex-felon disenfranchisement schemes are not only a bad policy, but also are incompatible with equal voting rights as embodied the 15th Amendment, and therefore invalid under law.
Type
text
citation_publisher
University of Utah
citation_keywords
Political rights, Loss of -- United States -- States ; Ex-convicts -- Suffrage -- United States
citation_dissertation_institution
University of Utah
citation_dissertation_name
Honors Bachelor of Science
citation_language
eng
Rights Management
(c)lauren Nicole Carpenter
Format-Medium
application/pdf (portable document)
Format-Extent
4,789,883 bytes
Identifier
etd2/id/1119
Conversion Specifications
Original scanned on Epson GT-30000 as 400 dpi to pdf using ABBYY FineReader 9.0 Professional Edition.
