Register of the Hamilton Gardner Papers,

Table of Contents

Collection Overview

Collection Inventory+/-

Biographical Note/Historical Note

Content Description

Collection Use

Administrative Information

Collection Overview +/-

Title: Hamilton Gardner Papers
Dates: 1942-1960 (inclusive)
Collection Number: Mss B 113
Summary: Attorney, historian, politician, civic leader, army officer. Correspondence, manuscripts, notes relating to Utah military history. Correspondence covers 1942 through 1960. The largest sections of the collection are the manuscripts of three unpublished books, a history of the Utah Expedition, a history of the Utah Territorial Militia, and a biography of Philip St. George Cooke. There are notes on the Utah Expedition from primary and secondary sources.
Repository: Utah State Historical Society

Collection Inventory +/-

Box Folder Contents
box , folder : Miscellaneous
box 1, folder 1 : Genealogical Data on Gardner and Barnum families; List of publications by Hamilton Gardner
box 1, folder 2 : Sketch and Clippings on James Hamilton Gardner
box 14, folder 1 : Military Circular, Headquarters Nauvoo Legion, 31 July 1857; General Order No. 1, Headquarters Nauvoo Legion, 25 Jun 1861; Map of Santa Fe Trace, drawn by Capt. P. St. G. Cooke, 1843
box 14, folder 2 : Map of the Oklahoma Region; Map of the Route of the 2d Dragoons in 1857; Map of Township No. 6, South of Range 2, 1890 (Fairfield and vicinity); Maps of Camp Floyd, 1859; Map of Ft. Crittenden Military Reservation, 1884
box 14, folder 3 : Miscellaneous papers from the Adjutant Generals Office on Lewis A. Huffaker, Jonathan Spencer, Henry V. Barnum
box 14, folder 4 : Appointment of Winfield Scott to the rank of Lt. General, 1854; Appointment of Albert S. Johnston to the rank of Brigadier General, 1857; Muster roll of Captain James Brown's Company C in the Mormon Battalion; Muster roll of Captain James Dafoe's Company D in the 27th Regiment, Michigan Infantry volunteers
box 14, folder 5 : Preston Nibley memorials to John R. Murdock (newspaper clippings)
box 14, folder 6 : Guia Del Archivo Historico Militar de Mexico, Tomo I, Taller Autografica, Mexico, D. F., 1949
box 14, folder 7 : Field Notes from Joseph Troskolawski's Survey of Camp Floyd Area, 1856
box 14, folder 8 : Porter, Hammind and Cooke's Appointments as Brig. Generals; Governor Cummings Appointment; Orders Relieving William S. Harney of Command; General Printed Orders for Utah Expedition
box 14, folder 9 : Letter to President Buchanan from W. M. F. Magraw, 3 October 1856; News Clipping; Letter Wolcott to Eunice, 1858 (soldier to sister); Letter John B. Floyd to Col. T. T. Fauntleroy, 1860
box 14, folder 10 : Letters Crary to Cooper, 1853; Ferguson to Cooper, 1852; Ferguson to Cooper, 1853 [National Archives]
box 14, folder 11 : Abstract of Annual Returns of the Militia of Utah Territory, 1851-1853 [National Archives]
box 14, folder 12 : Letter, James Buchanan regarding Utah Expedition
box 14, folder 13 : Letters, Buchanan from Charles C. Van Dyke and from Isaiah Rynder [Historical Society of Pennsylvania]
box , folder : Correspondence
box 1, folder 3 : November 1942 - September 1952
box 1, folder 4 : October 1952 - June 1953
box 1, folder 5 : July 1953
box 1, folder 6 : August - Decemember 1953
box 1, folder 7 : January 1954 - February 1955
box 1, folder 8 : April - October 1955
box 1, folder 9 : November 1955 - July 1957
box 1, folder 10 : March - July 1959
box 2, folder 1 : August 1959
box 2, folder 2 : August - December 1959
box 2, folder 3 : 1960
box , folder : Utah Expedition Draft
box 2, folder 4 : Foreword
box 2, folder 5 : Chapter 1: "The Grand Goal of All Our Marchings"
box 2, folder 6 : Chapter 2: "Those Twin Relics of Barbarism -- The Election of 1856"
box 2, folder 7 : Chapter 3: "A Good Army, Not a Large One -- The U.S. Army in 1857"
box 2, folder 8 : Chapter 4: "To Preserve the Peace and Repel Indian Depredations -- The Utah Territorial Militia in 1857"
box , folder : The Utah Territorial Militia [draft]
box 3, folder 1 : Preface and Introduction; Chapter 1: "Scope of the Study"; Chapter 2: "The Militia System of the United States"; Chapter 3: "The Nauvoo Legion of Illinois, 1840-1845"
box 3, folder 2 : Chapter 4: "The Mormon Battalion, 1846-1847"; Chapter 5: "The Militia Laws of the State of Deseret, 1849-1851
box 3, folder 3 : Chapter 6: "Original Militia Organizations Under the High Council and the State of Deseret, 1849-1851; Chapter 7: "The First Territorial Militia Law, 1852"
box 3, folder 4 : Chapter 8: "Early Growth of the Territorial Militia, 1852-1856"; Chapter 9: "The New Regulations Added by the Territorial Legislative Assembly, 1857"
box 3, folder 5 : Chapter 10: "A Major Militia Reorganization, 1857"; Chapter 11: "The Militia and the Utah Expedition, 1857-1858"
box 3, folder 6 : Chapter 12: "Federal Troops in Garrison at Camp Floyd-Fort Crittenden, 1858-1861"; Chapter 13: "The Militia and the Civil War, 1861-1865"; Chapter 14: "Training, Uniforms and Equipment, 1865"
box 3, folder 7 : Chapter 15: "Major Indian Depredations, 1865-1867"; Chapter 16: "Final Development of the Original Territorial Militia, 1866-1870"
box 3, folder 8 : Chapter 17: "Governor Shaffer vs General Wells, 1870"; Chapter 18: "Congress Abolishes the Nauvoo Legion, 1887"; Chapter 19: "Activation of the Utah National Guard, 1894"
box 3, folder 9 : Chapter 20: "Transition of the National Guard from Territorial to State Command, 1896; Acknowledgements; Military Abbreviations; Bibliography; Index
box 4, folder 1-12 : Drafts and Notes of Table of Contents through Chapter 9
box 5, folder 1-17 : Drafts and Notes of Chapters 10 trough Chapter 20 and miscellaneous
box , folder : Biography of Philip St. George Cooke Draft
box 6, folder 1 : Chapter 1: "A Son of the Old Dominion"
box 6, folder 2 : Chapter 2: "Education in West Virginia, 1816-1823"
box 6, folder 3 : Chapter 3: "The Army and the Pioneer West"
box 6, folder 4 : Chapter 4: "A Frontier Soldier"
box 6, folder 5 : Chapter 5: "A Cavalryman of the West"
box 6, folder 6 : Chapter 6: "The West Point Years, 1823-1828"
box 6, folder 7 : Chapter 7: "Down the Santa Fe Trail to the First Indian Battle, 1829"
box 6, folder 8 : Chapter 8: "Romance at Old Cantonment Leavenworth"
box 6, folder 9 : Chapter 9: "A Young West Pointer Reports on the Black Hawk War in 1832"
box 7, folder 1 : Chapter 10: "1st Lieutenant P. St. G. Cooke, an Officer-founder of the 1st Dragoons in 1833"
box 7, folder 2 : Chapter 11: "1st Lieutenant P. St. G. Cooke and the March of the 1st Dragoons from Jefferson Barracks to Fort Gibson in 1833-1834"
box 7, folder 3 : Chapter 12: "The Fateful Expedition to the Tow-e-ash Indian Council, 1834"
box 7, folder 4 : Chapter 13: "Carlisle Barracks, 1848-1852"
box 7, folder 5 : Chapter 14: "Fort Wayne, 1839-1840"
box 7, folder 6 : Chapter 15: "An International Sequel to A Journal of the Santa Fe Trail, 1843: The Vindication of Captain P. St. G. Cooke"
box 7, folder 7 : Chapter 15: "An International Sequel to A Journal of the Santa Fe Trail, 1843: The Vindication of Captain P. St. G. Cooke"
box 7, folder 8 : Chapter 16: "Captain P. St. G. Cooke and the March of the 1st Dragoons to the Rocky Mountains in 1845"
box 7, folder 9 : Chapter 16: "Captain P. St. G. Cooke and the March of the 1st Dragoons to the Rocky Mountains in 1845"
box 7, folder 10 : Chapter 17: "Captain P. St. George Cooke and the Occupation of Santa Fe in 1846"
box 7, folder 11 : Chapter 18: "A New Wagon Road to the Pacific, 1846-1847"
box 8, folder 1 : Chapter 19: "Report of Lt. Col. P. St. G. Cooke of his March from Santa Fe, New Mexico, to San Diego, Upper California"
box 8, folder 2-4 : Chapter 20: "Philip St. George Cooke and the Kearney-Fremont Controversy in 1847"
box 8, folder 5 : Chapter 21: "Lt. Col. P. St. G. Cooke and the Apache Campaigns in New Mexico, 1854"
box 8, folder 6 : Chapter 22: "Lt. Col. P. St. G. Cooke and the Sioux Campaign in Nebraska, 1855
box 8, folder 7 : Chapter 23: "Kansas, 1855-1857"
box 8, folder 8 : Chapter 24: "Report of Lt. Col. P. St. G. Cooke on the march of the 2nd Dragoons from Fort Leavenworth to Fort Bridger in 1857"
box 9, folder 1 : Notes on Biography of Philip St. George Cooke
box , folder : Miscellaneous drafts and manuscripts
box 9, folder 2-3 : "The Command and Staff of the Mormon Battalion in the Mexican War"
box 9, folder 4-6 : "Pioneer Military Leaders of Utah" [draft and notes]
box 10, folder 1 : "History of 222nd Field Artillery"
box 10, folder 2 : "Journal of a Territorial Militiaman at the Arrival of the Utah Expedition in 1857"
box 10, folder 3 : "Johnston's Army"
box 10, folder 4 : Possible Articles to be Written
box 10, folder 5-11 : National Archives Adjutant General Office [letters], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 10, folder 12 : National Archives Army of Utah [letters], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 1-3 : National Archives Army of Utah [letters], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 4 : National Archives Army of Utah [orders], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 5 : National Archives Army of Utah [orders]; Army of Utah [returns], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 6 : National Archives Army of Utah [returns], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 7 : National Archives Cartographic division (Notes), Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 8 : National Archives Justice Department, Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 9 : National Archives Photographs [notes], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 10 : National Archives Quartermaster General Office [contracts], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 11-12 : National Archives Secretary of War Office, Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 13 : National Archives Secretary of War, [letters], Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 14-15 : National Archives State Department, Utah Territorial Papers, Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 16 : National Archives Treasury Department, Notes on Utah and the Utah War
box 11, folder 17 : Boston Public Library, Newspaper Transcripts
box 11, folder 18 : Duke University, Governor Alfred Cummings Papers
box 11, folder 19-20 : Jesse A. Gove Letters, New Hampshire Historical Society, 1928
box 12, folder 1 : Historical Society of Pennsylvania
box 12, folder 2 : Library of Congress
box 12, folder 3-4 : Phelps, J. W. Diaries, New York Public Library
box 12, folder 5 : Scott, Charles A. Diary of Utah Expedition
box 12, folder 6 : Miller, John S. R. Papers; Ferguson, S. W. Memoirs; Long, Armistead L. - University of North Carolina
box 12, folder 7 : Virginia Historical Society
box , folder : Notes
box 12, folder 8 : Alter, J. Cecil, James Bridger,1925; Leonard Arrington, Great Basin Kingdom, 1958; H. H. Bancroft, History of Utah, 1889; Albert Beveridge, Abraham Lincoln, 1928
box 12, folder 9 : Brigance,William Norwood, Jeremiah S. Black, 1934; Edward Channing, A History of the United States,1905; George Ticknor Curtis, The Life of James Buchanan, 1883; Robert J. Dwyer, The Gentile Comes to Utah,1971; Norman Furniss, The Mormon Conflict, 1850-1859, 1960
box 12, folder 10 : Ganoe,William Addeman, The History of the U. S. Army,1942; LeRoy Hafen, Ft. Laramie; Elvin Hunt, History of Ft. Leavenworth, 1827-1927,1926; William Preston Johnston, The Life of Albert Sidney Johnston, 1878; John Bassett Moore, The Works of James Buchanan, 1910
box 12, folder 11 : Neff, Andrew Love, History of Utah, 1847-1869; Allan Nevins, Fremont, the West's Greatest Adventurer, 1928
box 12, folder 12 : Nevins, Allan, Ordeal of the Union
box 12, folder 13 : Pelzer, Louis, Marches of the Dragoons in the Mississippi Valley, 1917; Richard D. Poll, The Mormon Question, 1948
box 12, folder 14 : Rhodes, James Ford, History of the United States from the Compromise of 1850, 1896; Richardson, Compilation of the Messages of the Presidents
box 12, folder 15 : Roberts, B. J., Comprehensive History of the Church
box 12, folder 16 : Spaulding, Oliver Lyman, The U.S. Army in War and Peace, 1937; Edward Stanwood, A History of Presidential Elections, 1896; T. B. H. Stenhouse, The Rocky Mountain Saints, 1873; W. A. Swanberg, First Blood: The Story of Ft. Sumter; Tullidge, Salt Lake City; Ray B. West, Kingdom of the Saints, 1957; W. Woodruff, The Utah Pioneers, 1880
box 13, folder 1 : Misc. Notes
box 13, folder 1 1: Bancroft
box 13, folder 1 2: Creer
box 13, folder 1 3: Curtis
box 13, folder 1 4: Gove
box 13, folder 1 5: Hafen
box 13, folder 1 6: Neff
box 13, folder 1 7: Nevins
box 13, folder 1 8: Mulder
box 13, folder 1 9: Phelps
box 13, folder 1 10: Roberts
box 13, folder 1 11: Stenhouse
box 13, folder 1 12: Tracy
box 13, folder 1 13: Tullidge
box 13, folder 1 14: West
box 13, folder 1 15: Whitney
box 13, folder 2 : Misc. Notes A-Go
box 13, folder 2 1: Alexander, Edmund Brooke
box 13, folder 2 2: Black, Jeremiah S.
box 13, folder 2 3: Brown, Aaron Venable
box 13, folder 2 4: Buchanan, James
box 13, folder 2 5: Cass, Lewis
box 13, folder 2 6: Cobb, Howell
box 13, folder 2 7: Cooke, Philip St. George
box 13, folder 2 8: Cooper, Samuel
box 13, folder 2 9: Crittenden, Thomas L.
box 13, folder 2 10: Cumming, Alfred
box 13, folder 2 11: Fillmore, Millard
box 13, folder 2 12: Floyd, John B.
box 13, folder 2 13: Freeman, Douglas Southall
box 13, folder 2 14: Gove, Jesse A.
box 13, folder 3 : Misc. Notes Gu-R
box 13, folder 3 1: Gunnison, J. W.
box 13, folder 3 2: Jessup, Thomas Sidney
box 13, folder 3 3: Loring, William Wing
box 13, folder 3 4: Lowe, Percival G., Five Years a Dragoon, 1906
box 13, folder 3 5: Porter, Fitz-John
box 13, folder 3 6: Rodenbough, Theophilus F., From Everglades to Canon With the Second Dragoons, 1975
box 13, folder 4 : Misc. Notes S-W
box 13, folder 4 1: Scott, Winfield
box 13, folder 4 2: Slidell, John
box 13, folder 4 3: Thompson, Jacob
box 13, folder 4 4: Toucey, Isaac
box 13, folder 4 5: Tracy, Albert
box 13, folder 4 6: Waite, Carlos
box 13, folder 5 : Notes on Newspaper Articles
box 13, folder 6 : Notes on Public Documents
box 13, folder 7-8 : Miscellaneous Notes

Biographical Note/Historical Note +/-

Hamilton Gardner was an attorney, politician, civic leader, Army officer and historian. Gardner was born 4 January 1888, in West Jordan, Utah, a son of James H. and Rhoda (Huffaker) Gardner. He attended local secondary schools and spent several years at Brigham Young University in Provo, Utah. Later he served three years in missionary work for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Germany and Austria-Hungary. After being released from his mission he traveled widely through Italy, Greece and the Holy Land, being exposed to many other cultures and peoples. These experiences and those in the wars he would later serve in, contributed to a growing patriotism for his native country and concern over a perceived threat to it by other powers.

Returning to Utah, Gardner entered the University of Utah, where he was president of the student body in his senior year, graduating in 1913 with a Bachelor of Arts degree. Gardner was the grandson of a prominent Utah pioneer, Archibald Gardner, and early on became interested in the history of his family and the state they helped colonize. During his college years he made several attempts to write that history. His nascent literary talents found their first real expression with the publication of a history of the city of Lehi, Utah, where his father resided and where he was reared (History of Lehi, Salt Lake City: The Deseret News Press, 1913).

Soon after graduation from the University of Utah Gardner travelled East and entered Harvard University where he obtained an LL.B. degree in 1917. While at Harvard, in conjunction with his law studies, he continued to pursue a growing interest in the history of relations between the Mormons and the Federal government and published several articles on the subject in University's journal.

As Gardner was finishing his studies at Harvard, the United States became committed to the growing conflict in Europe. In April 1917 he began a long and distinguished military career when he volunteered for service in the United States Army. He received a commission in the Field Artillery, underwent training at several different camps, and in July 1918 embarked for France as a Captain in the 346th Artillery 91st Division. He served in France until February 1919 when he returned with his unit to the United States and was soon after released from active duty.

But Gardner's military service was not over. Following the war he helped develop the Utah National Guard and was promoted to Major of Cavalry in 1921. In 1926 he was promoted to Colonel and received command of his unit, the 222nd Field Artillery. Colonel Gardner commanded the unit until 1937 when he resigned. Considering his keen interest in and contributions to the Guard, the resignation was surprising to many, and his specific reasons are today vague. He indicated in a letter of resignation "I deeply regret severing my connection with the guard, because for 16 years I have been intensely interested, not only in the progress of my own regiment, but in the advancement of the national defense as a whole. But under the present setup of the national guard, I do not choose to serve any longer." The Adjutant General of the Utah National Guard stated that Gardner was noted for his outstanding ability, and it was with great reluctance that he accepted the resignation.

Following his return from the war, Gardner also began a successful law practice in Salt Lake City, being admitted to the Bar on 7 April 1919. In addition to building his practice he became a member of the University of Utah Law faculty and served as a member of the Utah State University Board of Trustees for several years. His political and academic accomplishments brought him national prominence following World War II when he accepted a position as an attorney for the National Labor Relations Board.

He also became active in various civic groups, bringing to expression the conservative, patriotic ideology of a die-hard Republican heritage and experience as an old-school Army officer. Ever since his travels through Europe he had been keenly aware of the world's vital problems and, in his words, "promoting one hundred percent Americanism." With that spirit Gardner was active in the organization of the American Legion in Utah and was elected its first commander.

Hamilton Gardner's grandfather, Bishop Archibald Gardner (noted Mormon pioneer and mill builder), had been a member of the Territorial Legislature; his father, James Hamilton Gardner, also figured prominently in Utah politics, serving as mayor and city council member of Lehi, commissioner of Utah County and a State Representative. Considering Hamilton's heritage and experience and concern with civic affairs, it was natural that he follow his father's and grandfather's lead. He served as a member of the Utah House of Representatives during 1925- 1926 (concurrently with his father) and the Utah State Senate 1927-1930 (serving as President of the Senate during 1929-1930). He continued his involvement with politics throughout his life.Gardner served as a member of the Utah House of Representatives during 1925-1926 (concurrently with his father) and the Utah State Senate 1927-1930 (serving as President of the Senate during 1929-1930).

Mr. Gardner never lost interest in his pioneer heritage and Utah history. Probably as a result of his experiences in the Army, he was particularly fascinated with Utah's military history during the territorial period. Specifically, he studied and wrote about the Mormon Battalion, the Utah War (1857-1861) Johnston's Army, and some of the prominent military and political figures of that era.

Following retirement, during the 1950s, Mr. Gardner began to pursue his writing in earnest. His dedication resulted in a move to Cambridge, Massachusetts where he spent his remaining years scouring Eastern archives and repositories for information to use in his books and articles. Gardner was a meticulous researcher; his voluminous notes reveal a passion for thoroughness. Since Gardner had no family at home, he filled his life with his work. But he passed away in 1961 (age 73) in Boston, with much of that work yet to be completed.

Content Description +/-

The majority of the collection consists of draft manuscripts and related rough notes; there are virtually no personal papers that would document Gardner's private life, which is, as a result, somewhat of a mystery. There are two brief compilations of genealogy on the Barnum (his maternal line) and the Gardner families. Although the information on his ancestors is good (a Scottish ancestry traced back to 1700), the information on Hamilton Gardner himself is very sketchy. Many of his manuscripts have been published. In the first folder, there is a bibliography of published works by Hamilton Gardner which can be compared to the inventory.

The majority of the first two boxes contain correspondence, most of which relates to the research and writing of the manuscripts in the collection. There are a great many routine letters to various repositories requesting information or copies, letters to publishers, answers to inquiries about his research and the like. The bulk of his correspondence was removed from folders containing the manuscripts to which the letters related. It was then organized chronologically for easier access and analysis of his ongoing work.

Boxes 2 through 7 contain drafts of his major works. The first is The Utah Expedition, an exhaustive monograph on the Utah War (1857-1861). The second, and related work, is The Utah Territorial Militia, which examines the history and organization of the militia which opposed Johnston's army during the Utah War. A third, and again related manuscript, is the Biography of Philip St. George Cooke, the Army officer who led the Mormon Battalion and later assumed command of Camp Floyd. These three major manuscripts make up the bulk of the collection. They are organized sequentially by chapter, with the chapter titles given in the inventory.

In boxes 9 and 10 there is a section of miscellaneous manuscripts. These are articles on various topics related to the period of the Utah War. There are also draft outlines and a folder on "possible articles to be written." Continuing in box 10 and 12 are notes and bibliographies collected during Gardner's research in Eastern archives. These notes are organized alphabetically by the name of the collections researched.

In his studies, Gardner also consulted many secondary works. There is a vast quantity of bibliographic material in the collection (boxes 12 and 13). In addition, there are notes from various published works (on many subjects) and notes on various persons and events (from many different sources). They are organized in alphabetical order accordingly. The final box (Box 14) contains a collection of documents pertaining to his primary subjects such as maps, military circulars, appointment certificates, copies of orders and letter, etc. This material is itemized in the inventory.

Collection Use +/-

Restrictions on Access:

Restrictions on Access

Administrative Information +/-

Arrangement:

Creator:

Gardner, Hamilton, 1888-1961.

Language:

English.

Sponsor:

Library Services and Technology Act (LSTA) grant, 2007-2008

Quantity:

14 boxes (7 linear ft.)

Language of the Finding Aid:

Finding aid written in Englishin Latin script

EAD Creation Date:

1999.